Playbook 01 · Deliverability
How many sending domains and mailboxes do you need for cold email?
Short answer
Plan for about 25 cold emails per mailbox per day and 2–3 mailboxes per domain. Divide your daily volume by 25 to get mailboxes, divide that by 3 to get domains, then add 20–30% spare so you can rest anything that starts to slip. Never send cold email from your main company domain.
Most cold email problems that look like copy problems are infrastructure problems. Emails that never reach the inbox can’t get replies, however good the first line is. Sizing your sending setup correctly is the first thing to get right.
The rule of thumb
Three numbers do most of the work:
- About 25 cold emails per mailbox per day. Some teams push 40–50; 25 leaves headroom and keeps each mailbox looking like a person, not a machine.
- 2–3 mailboxes per domain. Spreading volume across domains means one bad day doesn’t take everything down.
- 20–30% spare capacity. Mailboxes need resting when their placement slips. Spares let you rest them without missing your volume.
So the formula is:
- Mailboxes = daily sends ÷ 25
- Domains = mailboxes ÷ 3 (round up)
- Add 20–30% to both.
Sizing at a glance
| Daily emails (all steps) | Mailboxes (≈25/day) | Domains (3 per) | With 25% spare capacity |
|---|---|---|---|
| 100 | 4 | 2 | 5 mailboxes · 2 domains |
| 300 | 12 | 4 | 15 mailboxes · 5 domains |
| 600 | 24 | 8 | 30 mailboxes · 10 domains |
| 1,000 | 40 | 14 | 50 mailboxes · 17 domains |
Remember that follow-ups count. A three-step sequence to 100 new contacts a day ends up sending close to 300 emails a day once it is running. Size for the total, not just first touches.
Set each domain up properly
Volume only works if receiving servers trust you. For every sending domain:
- SPF, DKIM and DMARC configured and passing. Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft now expect authenticated mail, and unauthenticated mail is increasingly filtered or rejected.
- A lookalike of your brand (for example
getyourbrand.comoryourbrandhq.com) that redirects to your real site, so a curious prospect lands somewhere legitimate. - Warm-up for two to three weeks before real sends, and keep it running.
- Custom tracking domain if you track clicks, or switch link and open tracking off. Shared tracking domains drag everyone down together.
- An easy opt-out in every email, and honour it straight away.
Watch the numbers that matter
Sending capacity is useless if placement collapses. Each week, check:
- Inbox placement with seed tests across Gmail, Outlook and other providers.
- Bounce rate — keep it low by verifying every address before it enters a sequence.
- Spam complaints — Google’s guidance for bulk senders is to stay below 0.3%, and well under 0.1% is the safe zone.
When a mailbox’s placement drops, pause it, let warm-up recover it, and lean on your spares. That’s what the 20–30% buffer is for.
Where teams usually go wrong
- Sending from the main domain to “save time”. It saves a week and risks the domain your whole business runs on.
- Buying domains the week of launch. Warm-up then delays everything by three weeks.
- Scaling volume to fix low replies. If replies are low, the targeting or the message is the problem. More volume just reaches more of the wrong people faster.
- No monitoring. Problems surface as “replies dried up” two weeks after the damage started.
How we do it
On every engagement we buy and set up the sending domains in the client’s name on day one, so warm-up runs while we build the targeting. For one growth agency we rebuilt the whole sending layer — domains, authentication, warmed inboxes and monitoring — so problems surfaced before a domain burned, and documented it so they could repeat it for each new client.
Questions people also ask
01Can I send cold email from my main company domain?
You can, but you shouldn't. If a campaign draws spam complaints, the damage lands on the domain your team uses for customers, invoices and hiring. Use separate sending domains that redirect to your main site.
02How long does domain warm-up take?
Plan on two to three weeks of gradual warm-up before a new mailbox sends real campaigns, and keep warm-up running in the background afterwards. Start warm-up on day one of any project so it is never the bottleneck.
03Should I use Google Workspace or Microsoft 365 mailboxes?
A mix of both is common, because it spreads risk across providers and tends to match the mix of inboxes you are sending into. What matters more is that every mailbox is properly authenticated and warmed.
04Does a bigger volume mean more meetings?
Not on its own. Past a point, more volume mostly buys more spam complaints. Better targeting — writing to accounts showing a buying signal — usually lifts meetings more than adding mailboxes.